Friday, September 21, 2012

Mitt Romney gets Democrats to admit he pays too much in taxes

Like most everyone else, I got my first look at Mitt Romney's 2011 Tax Return today and a bullet point style letter prepared by PWC summarizing 20 years of returns (http://www.mittromney.com/disclosure/letter-from-pwc).  Given PWC's history of being accused of signing fraudulent tax documents and agreeing to pay large sums of money to settle those charges I have no doubt that they would not jeopardize their integrity by writing a summary letter stating what a Presidential candidate asked them to state.  I also won't get into the fact that capital gains taxes were much higher during the first 10 years of period than the last 10 years so the fact he paid an average tax over 20% isn't all that surprising or relevant.  Instead, I want to focus on his generous charitable contributions.

The $4,020,772 he gave to charity last year is impressive and undoubtedly provided great benefits to those who received them.  I would even venture to say it provided more benefit than it would have if he paid taxes on it as income instead of donating it.  Much of it probably went to the 47% of Americans who pay no federal taxes.  Honestly, I am not sure why he isn't praising these people instead of demonizing them.  He himself proudly stated earlier this year "I pay all of the taxes I am legally required to pay and not a dollar more".  Why can't the 47% be equally as proud of paying all the taxes they are legally required to pay?  But I digress...  I want to stay focused on his generous charitable contributions.

The piece I want to focus on is the additional roughly $250k Mitt was generous enough to donate to the Federal government!  Yes, you read that correctly, Mitt only claimed $2.25M of his $4M of charitable donations which in turn amounted to him giving the Federal government a $250k donation.  I'll show my work for those who want to follow the math... $4M - $2.25M = $1.75M * 14.1% effective tax rate = $250k (yes, I am rounding for convenience and effect).  Now the cynical side wants to say Mitt did this so Democrats would scream "Mitt paid too much in taxes" which many have already started championing.  These are going to make for great commercials this fall.

However, I think the reason for this donation goes much deeper and even further than his campaign's statement that this was done so Mitt could continue to stand behind his claim that "in the past 10 years I have never paid an effective tax rate below 13%".  I will let you do the math on this one, but if Mitt took the entire $4M deduction he was entitled to it would have dropped his effective tax rate below 13%.  I believe this donation is part of Mitt's grand plan to balance the budget and cut taxes at the same time.  If Mitt is able to convince the other 5.1M millionaires in the US to make this same donation it would generate $1.3 TRILLION in additional revenue.  If you are wondering why that $1.3T number sounds familiar to you, it is the same number Hal Mason reports in his budget dilemma video as the budget deficit for 2012.

Let me be the first to say, Mitt Romney has done his part to solve the budget deficit and hopefully he can convince the other 5.1M millionaires to follow his example.  If he can do that he will get this Democrats vote!

Monday, September 10, 2012

The sky is blue!

A while back I got into a huge argument with one of my close friends.  We went back and forth for quite a while with each of us growing more and more frustrated with the other by the minute.  Finally he screamed "I'M DONE, you would disagree with me on anything just to cause an argument!"  I responded with "that's not true" which sent him into a further tirade because again I disagreed with him.

Finally he said "The sky is blue" and I replied "you're right".  He smiled and said "at least we can agree on the sky being blue, I guess there is hope for us yet".  I should have just left it at that but for some reason I let my mouth open and out came... "No, I don't agree with you that the sky is blue, I agree that I would disagree with you if you said "the sky is blue"".  After a long series of expletives he stormed off saying he wasn't going to waste anymore time with someone who wouldn't listen to facts and reason.  Not to be out done, I yelled back that it was impossible to have a conversation with someone that changes their opinion more often than the weather! 

That night I couldn't sleep as I continued to replay the argument over and over in my head.  Was he right?  Did I not really believe my point of view and just wanted to argue with him?  Was I unwilling to change my opinion even after presented with facts and reason? Finally about 3:00 AM I couldn't take it any longer and knew I would never get any sleep if I didn't make things right with him.  I dialed his number and asked just one question...  "Now what color do you think the sky is?" 

Saturday, September 08, 2012

Hal Mason pretends to explain the United States Budget Dilemma




I can't think of a better topic to relaunch this site with than this little nugget from Hal.  The video claims to be ALARMING! and at first glance I was even alarmed.  I mean wholly crap there is no way for the US to ever balance the budget!  However the images of the twin towers exploding seemed a little over the top for any life long accountant I know and when I saw it was being posted on every conservative website the jig was up.  Time to do the math (a phrase I often use because it for some reason drives some of my "friends" to near levels of insanity).

I stumbled through the same process Hal laid out in his presentation and arrived at the exact same conclusion!  I was truly horrified, but something still didn't seem quite right (actually it seemed to far right to be true).  I buy into the concept that "numbers don't lie", but my 25 years of business experience told me that presenters often distort them.  Time to dig a little deeper and flip through a couple more pages of the 2013 budget...  what a minute, if this is the 2013 budget why is Hal asking us to take a look at the 2012 numbers?  Umm, this very first summary table on page 205 of the budget seems interesting.  It shows revenue as a % of GDP for 2012 at 15.8% and then growing steadily to slightly over 20% over the next 10 years.  That is pretty interesting, I wonder if I looked at 2022 or even 2013 it would show me a budget that was able to be balanced without eliminating the entire federal government?  Guess what...  Hal picked 2012 because his entire premise falls apart if you use 2013 (from the 2013 budget proposal).

Having spent some time recently sharping my skills with the puppets from the right I knew this wasn't going to be enough.  I needed to go deeper and do some more math.  Time to see what the historical average was for revenue as a percent of GDP.  Let's see, my Google search shows...  ooh, something on the Heritage.org website . Tough to dismiss this one as "a liberal rag in the tank for Obama".  Even better, it is a chart used to defend extending the Bush tax cuts!  I will let you see for yourself what they have to say (http://www.heritage.org/federalbudget/current-tax-receipts).  So the recession was the cause for the current low revenue and as the growth returns revenue will return to slightly above the historical 18.2% average with all Bush's tax cuts extended.  I am guessing the President's budget doesn't reflect all of Bush's cuts being extended and that's why he shows it just over 20% which coincidentally is the same level in 2000, a year before Bush took office, but I'll let you do your own math on it.

Now that we see Hal intentionally mislead us (no such thing as an "honest mistake" for a career accountant posting a youtube video using images of a national tragedy for emphasis), let's get back to the real problem which our debt currently stands at over $16 trillion and will grow to over $25 trillion by 2022 according to the President's budget.  Note, even Paul Ryan's plan doesn't produce a balanced budget until 2040.  Bottom line, we need to find a fix for our mandatory budget items (medicare, medicaid, social security, etc) so they are self funding, cut our discretionary spending (basically funding for the entire federal government, including defense) and further INCREASE revenues (yeah that means more taxes).  A little bit of irony as it is the exact same prescription Hal gave us! 

Monday, March 27, 2006

Welcome

Say it loud and say it proud...  I am a Democrat!